Editorial -
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 Sir: Re: Letter to the editor from P.C. Clare,
"Candidate stances on WSIB important" (The Observer, Aug. 23, 2007)
The letter is factually incorrect on absolutely every point. I will respond to
each of the outrageous and irresponsible accusations directly to Ontario's MPPs
as it would be too exhaustive a reply for this forum. However, there are
several allegations made by P.C. Clare that I believe require immediate
clarification.
The majority of Clare's accusations are obviously
subjective and certainly unsubstantiated. While Clare has a right to express an
opinion, it is my view that this does not include the right to irresponsibly
castigate the men and women who strive every day to help injured workers. I am
very proud of the staff of the WSIB (Workplace Safety and Insurance Board) and
their dedication to the work they do at every level within the organization is
unparalleled.
The WSIB is committed to assisting injured workers to
regain a meaningful and productive life. To suggest our efforts are responsible
for injured worker suicides is both inflammatory and preposterous. If someone
tragically takes his or her own life, we all lose. I can assure you, WSIB
claimants are treated with dignity and respect and effective internal and
external appeals processes do exist should they wish to see the decisions of
our adjudicators reconsidered.
As the majority of Ontarians are aware,
the WSIB is an agency of the provincial government responsible to the Ministry
of Labour for implementing the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act. We do not
make laws; that responsibility rests wholly with the elected representatives of
the legislature of Ontario. The WSIB is fully accountable to the Ontario
government and our operations are subject to scrutiny by the Fair Practices
Commission.
The WSIB chairperson's salary is not $700,000 per year;
not even remotely close. I do this work because I am passionate about
eliminating the carnage that occurs in Ontario workplaces every year. In fact,
the position of chairperson of the WSIB is a part-time appointment by Order in
Council of the provincial government. But I can tell you without fear of
contradiction, I and everyone at the WSIB work on a more than full-time basis
to help make Ontario's workplaces the safest in the world.
My door is
always open to assist anyone in understanding the value the WSIB brings to
Ontario's workers, injured workers and the employers who fund the system. Our
number one mandate is to prevent injuries, illnesses and fatalities and we all
need to work together to that end.
Finally to P.C. Clare I say this:
Do your homework. Your unfounded statements have done more to hurt the cause of
injured workers in Ontario than to benefit them. We all need to do more to
eliminate workplace injuries and fatalities and to accomplish this we need to
be honest. Your letter was at best misinformed and at worst dishonest. However,
I will give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you are just horribly
misinformed.
HISTORY: Aug. 23, 2007 -
injured worker asks questions about the WSIB to Ontario provincial election
candidates in newspaper: - Letter to the editor from P.C. Clare,
"Candidate stances on WSIB important" - (The
Observer, Aug. 23, 2007) - Aug. 29, 2007 - WSIB
responds negatively in letter to same newspaper: - Response to P.
C. Clare from WSIB Chairperson, Steven W. Mahoney,
"Chairperson defends record of the WSIB" (The
Observer, Aug. 29, 2007) Aug. 29, 2007 - the CIWS
responds to both letters: -
Response from the CIWS to the
Sarnia Observer Editorials re: Mr. Mahoney (WSIB) and Mr. Clare's Letters -
sent August 29, 2007 - (Published in the
Sarnia
Observer Set 5 2007) Sept. 11, 2007 - PC
Clare's response: All Injured Workers Need Fair
Treatment October 4, 2007 - PC Clare
receives answers from Steve Mahoney and responds: Answers on WSIB
insufficient